Fraud protection is the biggest worry among bank and credit card customers. Fraud losses hit a record $16 billion in 2025. But the JD Power 2026 U.S. Financial Protection Satisfaction Study,SM released today, finds declining customer satisfaction. The findings show a clear gap between what customers expect and what providers do.
Capital One ranks highest among banks in account protection satisfaction. Meanwhile, American Express ranks highest among credit card issuers.
“Customers want their bank or card issuer to spot suspicious activity early, explain what’s happening as resolution progresses and stay with them until they feel their financial control is restored,” said Jennifer White, managing director for banking and payments intelligence at JD Power. “That starts before fraud occurs, with clear guidance on how to protect accounts. When fraud does happen, customers should know how to report it quickly and then be advised when they’ll hear back regarding resolution. The goal shouldn’t be just stopping a fraudulent transaction, it should also be making sure customers feel in control again.”
Providers Miss Chances to Guide Customers
First, providers rarely nudge customers to act. More than half of bank customers (52%) say their provider has not prompted them to review security settings. Similarly, 58% of credit card customers report the same experience.
Gaps in reporting compound the problem. 18% of bank customers and 19% of credit card customers who experienced fraud did not contact their provider. 30% of bank customers and 29% of credit card customers who remained silent said it was because of bad past experiences with their provider’s fraud department.
Clear instructions also make a big difference. Among bank customers, 84% reviewed their settings when instructions were completely clear. In contrast, only 56% did so when instructions were partially clear or unclear.
What Customers Want From Account Protection
Customers Fraud Protection also prefer a firm response to suspected fraud. Two-thirds (66%) of bank customers and 67% of credit card customers want their provider to decline a suspicious purchase. By comparison, just 22% in each group would rather let the purchase go through with an alert.
Third-party data sharing offers another opportunity. Overall satisfaction rises 148 points on a 1,000-point scale for bank customers when providers proactively review account data sharing. Likewise, credit card customers report a 135-point increase. Despite these gains, only 6% of bank customers and 4% of credit card customers say their provider offers this review.
Follow-up also falls short. After resolution, 24% of bank customers and 25% of credit card customers say their provider did not follow up. Yet a strong recovery can build loyalty. Four in 10 customers walk away with a more positive impression, including 42% of bank customers and 43% of credit card customers.
Explore Finance Tech News for the latest innovations in financial technologies and expert insights shaping the future of digital finance!
News Source: Businesswire.com